Rigorous International Selection Process Identifies Three Top Studies from Among Ten Finalists
(26 July 2019) Now in its seventh year, the Best of UNICEF Research competition continues its tradition of inspiring rigorous and influential evidence across the global organization. Each year, UNICEF offices around the world – including country offices, regional offices, national committees, and headquarters – are invited to submit their best and most recent examples of research for children. The aim is to bring attention to work that contributes to shifting policy agendas and has a high potential for impact on policies and programmes that benefit children.
Showcasing some of the most innovative and rigorous research coming out of UNICEF, this year’s winners cover a range of topics, locations, cultures and levels of economic development, including education in India, violence in the Middle East and North Africa, humanitarian aid in the Democratic Republic of Congo, migration, child rights, sanitation and more. This year, UNICEF Innocenti identified 10 finalists which were then independently reviewed by an external panel of international experts.
Acknowledging their originality, strong conceptualization, sound methodology, and high potential for impact, the 2019 external review panel identified the following three research projects for special recognition among the 10 finalists:
The India Early Childhood Education Impact Study
Produced by the Centre for Early Childhood Education and Development (CECED), the Aser Centre and UNICEF India. The panel commended the rigorous nature of this research as well as the methods adopted to assess the quality of early childhood education programs. As an observational, longitudinal study, poor and marginalized children were followed for 4 years in two districts of the 3 Indian states of Telangana, Assam and Rajasthan. The choice of measures and assessment tools are considered appropriate and clearly highlight the links between school readiness and subsequent early grade outcomes.
Violent discipline in the Middle East and North Africa Region
Produced by UNICEF MENA Regional Office. The panel lauded this piece for its original contribution to a sensitive, yet policy relevant topic for vulnerable populations in the MENA region. The report employs a multidisciplinary approach to analyze secondary data available in the region, notably the MICS and DHS modules on violence against children. It also provides a comprehensive analysis of survey data on violent discipline among children aged 2-14 years.
Effects of Humanitarian Assistance: Evidence from a Randomized Control Trial in the Democratic Republic of Congo
Produced by the International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie), DRC Humanitarian Pooled Fund, UNOCHA and UNICEF DR Congo. The panel found this report to fill an important gap in the literature by providing rigorous evidence with a counterfactual on the impacts of vouchers in humanitarian settings. Also, the researchers demonstrated their commitment to rigorous research within a complex environment and adopted creative solutions to overcome some implementation obstacles. Overall, the presentation is well-targeted to a practitioner audience, but at the same time demonstrates rigorous methods and high academic standards.
UNICEF Innocenti is pleased to see that India is not only ranked as a finalist but also as a top three this year having previously ranked as finalist in 2017. We also note that research from the MENA region is now featuring as a top-three finalist for the third year in a row (the two previous editions being submissions from Egypt and Palestine). It is also exciting to see a new entrant – DR Congo – shortlisted as a finalist and a top three this year. Submissions for the 2019 Best of UNICEF Research were received from different thematic areas, the most prevalent being child protection, health and cross-cutting themes.
THE IMPORTANCE OF ETHICS
Following the introduction of the UNICEF Procedure for Ethical Standards in Research, Evaluation, Data Collection and Analysis in 2015 and a subsequent review of Best of UNICEF Research assessment criteria in 2016, ethical considerations are now being given an increasingly high priority, meaning that any submissions that fell short of ethical standards were not considered for shortlisting. UNICEF Innocenti is committed to ensuring that all research undertaken by UNICEF and its partners is ethical and is currently working towards establishment of a UNICEF-wide Ethics Review Board.
THE TOP 10 SUBMISSIONS
The external panel noted the robustness and quality of research in all 10 finalists’ submissions and specifically noted their added policy relevance. The panel further noted the potential replicability of the reports in other countries/contexts.
The panel also commented that they were faced with the challenge of selecting the best three pieces from a variety of high-quality research outputs. Congratulations to all 10 finalists for their particularly strong submissions:
- Ethiopia: Financing the child centered Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in Ethiopia
- Ethiopia: Situation and access to services of people with disabilities and homeless people in two sub-cities of Addis Ababa
- Cambodia: Water quality for young children in Cambodia – High contamination a collection and consumption level
- Democratic Republic of Congo: Effects of Humanitarian Assistance: Evidence from a Randomized Control Trial in the Democratic Republic of Congo
- ECARO: Age Matters! Understanding age-related barriers to service access and the realisation of rights of children, adolescents and youth
- Philippines: HiFive for HySan Pilot Evaluation
- WCARO: Lessons from the West Africa Ebola Epidemic: A Systematic Review of Epidemiological and Social and Behavioral Science Research Priorities
- MENARO: Violent discipline in the Middle East and North Africa Region
- United Kingdom: Education for Refugee and Asylum-Seeking Children: Access and equality in England, Scotland and Wales
- India: The India Early Childhood Education Impact Study
UNICEF staff can read all 10 reports on our Teamsite.
For those outside of UNICEF, the Best of UNICEF Research Report will be available online and in print by the end of the year. In the meantime, you can explore previous Best of UNICEF Research publications.
Thank you to our external panel for their time and comments. The panel was composed of Marie-Claude Martin (Former Innocenti Deputy Director and currently Senior Fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation and Director of Global Initiatives at the Alliance for Human Development), Alex Ezeh (Professor of Global Health at the Dornsife School of Public Health, Drexel University and Distinguished Visiting Fellow at the Center for Global Development), Ruth Levine (former Program Director of Global Development and Population at the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation), Sabu Padmadas (Professor of Demography and Global Health at the University of Southampton), and Ricardo Fuentes-Nieva (Chief Executive Officer, OXFAM Mexico).